Manifesto: The 21st Century Will Be Defined By Games – part 2
The Ludic Century: Exploring The Manifesto
by Heather Chaplin
In 2008, at the Games, Learning and Society Conference in Wisconsin, Eric and I held a public conversation about what he called The Ludic Century – or as I came to think of it, because most people don’t know what “ludic” means, the Age of Play. As a journalist covering videogames, I’d watched as they flipped into the mainstream and spread throughout digital culture, in the form of ‘gamification’ and beyond. I heard people say that while the moving image had been the right medium for the 20th century, the videogame would be the dominant medium of the 21st. I saw it happening, but I kept wondering why. Why did games speak to people so strongly at this particular moment, and how was this shift going change us?
Over the following years, Eric and I spent an inordinate amount of time discussing these things. At the same time, game studies was taking off, and the MacArthur Foundation was giving grants to game designers like Eric and Katie Salen, and academics like James Paul Gee and Henry Jenkins. Two big ideas emerged from the amazing conversations of that time, and form the heart of Eric’s manifesto:
Complex systems and systems thinking
A complex system is a set of interconnected parts that together form a whole larger than the sum of the parts. Remove any one part and the whole thing changes. Your body is a complex system; global weather is a complex system; the Internet is a complex system. A videogame is a complex system, too. The big revelation was that if videogames were complex systems then playing them might help foster ‘systems thinking’.
Systems thinking – according to Peter Senge of the Center for Organizational Learning at MIT – is “a discipline for seeing wholes. It is a framework for seeing interrelationships rather than things, for seeing patterns of change rather than static snapshots.” Systems thinking probes the underlying nature of how things work. To survive in a time of increasing complexity, becoming a systems thinker would be key. Could it be that an especially maligned group – gamers – might be preparing themselves uniquely well for the challenges of the future?1
Play
It’s crucial to understand that play isn’t solely a juvenile activity, though we often associate it with the young. Play is how mammals learn. Babies and children play as a way of developing their understanding of the world – but as John Seeley Brown, the former chief scientist of Xerox Park [sic, PARC], told me recently, it’s essential that adults be able to play as well. We’ve “transitioned into a time of transitions,” Seeley Brown argues – and the only way we can adjust ourselves to the present-day speed of change is to become as adept at play as a baby, dropped into a world about which she knows nothing.
And play constitutes pushback against the boundaries of a system established by rules. Man-made systems – the tax system, the school system, society as a whole – can be oppressive. In a world increasingly dominated by such systems, play could become a crucial even subversive act.
The Dark Side
As Eric and I talked, I began to hear a nagging voice in my head: would life in the Ludic Century really be as rosy as we’d initially thought?
The neurologist Simon Baron-Cohen argues that there are two kinds of brains: one hardwired for empathy and one hardwired for building and understanding systems. (The former is usually a female brain and the latter a male brain, in Baron-Cohen’s account – but let’s put that aside for now.) He writes: “Empathizing is the drive to identify another person’s emotions and thoughts, and to respond to them with an appropriate emotion.” Systemizing, on the other hand, “is the drive to analyze, explore and construct a system.”2
If it’s true that we’re moving into a Ludic Century – an era that rewards and elevates this systemizing personality type – what happens to emotional intelligence and empathy? Does too much focus on the whole create a danger of neglecting the human parts? Are we moving into a future in which plenty of people are logical, good at recognizing patterns, and analyzing the way things work, but in which fewer and fewer of us are able to empathize?
Another risk is that we might fail to see the commercial videogame industry for what it really is. Call of Duty and Medal of Honor may promote systems thinking – but these games also promote a militarized worldview, and could serve as advertisement for a particular kind of American foreign policy. (This is to be distinguished from the highly dubious claim that gaming triggers aggression in gamers.) More generally, a lot modern gaming constitutes what psychologists call “dark play,” focusing on death and violence. Dark play is a natural and vital part of human moral development: “Ring-a-round the Rosie”, according to legend, helped the children who originally sang it comprehend the Great Plague. But dark play used to arise organically. When major corporations have a strong incentive to promote it, do we risk losing the right balance between different kinds of play?3
I’ve been consistently astounded to discover that even the smartest game designers don’t seem interested in this questions. If Eric’s manifesto is a vision of the future – and I think it’s a hugely valuable contribution to our thinking about that future – we surely shouldn’t ignore the potential downsides.4
In the coming days we’ll be soliciting feedback to Eric’s manifesto from a host of game designers and thinkers. We hope you’ll join in.
Manifesto for a Ludic Century will appear in the upcoming MIT Press book The Gameful World, edited by Steffen P. Walz and Sebastian Deterding.
Eric Zimmerman is a 20-year veteran of the game industry and has designed award-winning games on and off the computer. He is an Arts Professor at the NYU Game Center. He can be found online at his website EricZimmerman.com and on his blog, ericzimmerman.wordpress.com.
Heather Chaplin is an assistant professor of journalism at The New School and the author of Smartbomb: The Quest for Art, Entertainment and Big Bucks in the Videogame Revolution (2005). She reports on games for All Things Considered.