In classic game-theory experiments called Tit-for-Tat, what emerges organically as the best strategy for building a functioning society is called “strong reciprocity.” You help me, I help you. You hurt me, I hurt you back. This pattern of rewarding norm-compliance and punishing norm-violation holds things together more effectively than either presumptive mistrust or pure altruism. This is how it is in real life, too. As someone raised in a face-conscious Chinese family and now active in cross-partisan citizen engagement, I’ve long been attuned to how face plays out in different contexts. Across all cultures, the basic deal is that face is properly invoked only when both sides in an interaction share a prior set of prosocial norms: propriety (what Confucius called “gentlemanliness”); mutual obligation (what both Confucius and Adam Smith, in his Theory of Moral Sentiments, called “benevolence”); strong reciprocity; and, not least, a capacity for shame.