Along the lines of that Gregory quote, I’ve become increasingly suspicious of sentiments that paint satire as “traditionally the weapon of the powerless against the powerful,” as this Molly Ivans quote would have it. (Though I agree with all the commentary under the quote, and lord knows I hope Molly Ivans now spends her days getting tipsy at the celestial bar with Dorothy Parker and Ann Richards.) It seems more likely that satire has, through historical accident, come to be seen as socially liberal due far more to the way it’s been used – most notably by Swift, but also Twain and the Yippies and the Daily Show – than any of its formal qualities. Because satire has been used in the past to oppose child labor and lynching and the Vietnam War, new uses of satire tend to resonate more when they’re being put to socially liberal uses; we accept a piece of creative expression’s message much more readily if it aligns with the ways that type of expression has been used in the past. (We don’t question it when one person with a gun kills fifty other people with guns in an action movie, but would certainly do so if it happened in a biopic.) But I don’t think there’s anything inherently populist about satire, and if anything it’s a little too arch to be truly rabble-rousing. It can work to the purposes you put it to, or it can’t. It’s just another way of communicating.
I think there’s a tendency when talking about comedy – a tendency that I have very much been guilty of! – to overrate its qualities in trying to combat its traditionally less-than-respectable reputation. I don’t think that does it any favors, ultimately. Claiming that comedy can accomplish certain things we value better than do serious forms of expression sets it up to fail. Comedy is a relatively more complicated way of communicating (except when farts are involved), so there’s no real reason to think it would be more effective at getting across messages – and, indeed, most studies have shown that it isn’t. (It can improve knowledge a bit when working in conjunction with non-comedic forms of communication, but those serious sources have to be there first.) Instead, it might be more useful to think about what other goods can come from comedy as a creative form, and allow ourselves to be open to new processes, or previously disreputable processes, like emotion or pleasure.
That’s why I liked that Gregory quote so much. Asking comedy to do what we already ask serious forms of expression to do doesn’t really advance our knowledge beyond wishful thinking. That’s what I think Gregory was saying: we all know comedy isn’t a weapon, because comedian make awful warlords. If we think comedy is accomplishing something in society, we have to be clear-eyed about what comedy is, and then figure out how we got from point A to point B. Gregory is suggesting that “disappointment within a friendly relation” leads, in some way, to changes in attitude. To me, that seems like a much more interesting idea than that the mere act of satire aligns you with the angels.