A node in a network is not the same as a “cause.”


shrinkrants:

I like this clear example of a tiresomely common logical error in “scientific” writing about things psychological these days:

tyrenshaw:

“Note that our reasons for avoiding pain are not supplied by studies of thalamic nuclei or of the substantia gelatinosa or of the periaquaductal gray. So-called pain “centers” or pain “mechanisms” are but anatomical places whose activity is reliably correlated with that ultimate and irreducible existential fact, It hurtsl The fact of pain in neither confirmed nor validated by some (allegedly) more fundamental event, some neural event. Rather, the neural event takes on its significance only by virtue of its agreement with the psychological occurence. We avoid what is painful because it is painful, period. We do not avoid it because of the substantia gelatinosa, period. And so even if we had nothing less than a nomological-deductive account of human neural systems, we would not be able to explain human reactions to pain, and this inability would survive even if we were able to predict and control the reactions in question.” 

— Daniel N. Robinson, “Explaining Social Phenomena” (1986, p. 21)