Gibson reads literary trends as a kind of window into our collective
fears and desires about the future – he notes that while the 20th
century was rife with speculation about the 21st; here in the early
decades of 21C we almost never talk about 2200 and beyond (I wonder if
that’s not just a function of the fact that we’re in the first half of
the 21st century, while most sf was written in the back half of 20C).
Where things get sharp is where Gibson points out that huge swathes of
the human population are living in dystopias as grim as any cyberpunk
future (“dystopia is not evenly distributed”). In the 1960s, during the
civil rights movement’s heyday, LBJ said “If you can convince the lowest
white man he’s better than the best colored man, he won’t notice you’re
picking his pocket,” while Trump’s 2016 campaign was a long exercise in
telling poor white people that they may end up in the same dire straits
that racialized Americans had navigated since the colonialism’s first
genocidal years on the continent – proving the corollary to LBJ,
namely, convincing white people they may be the next underclass will
stampede them into voting for anyone who promises to stop it.
The steady accumulation of wealth at the top of the income distribution
since the Reagan years are a kind of macroscopic version of the Trump
phenomenon: if you want to convince first-worlders that the end-times
are coming, simply convince them that they will live in the dystopian
conditions that already prevail elsewhere, confirm their lurking anxiety
that the privilege they’ve enjoyed was an accident of history and not a
vote of confidence in their innate superiority. Convince them that they
are one bad beat away from having kids with swollen bellies lying
outside rude huts, too weak to brush the flies away from their eyes.
I think this is the special genius of The Handmaid’s Tale: by
putting a white, educated, formerly middle-class woman in the position
of a sex-slave to a religious fascist – by putting a North American in
the place of a woman under the Taliban or Isis – the entwined destiny
and fragility of all people on earth (including those in the unevenly
distributed dystopias of the Rest of the World) is manifested and our
worst fears are confirmed.
There are other reasons that dystopian stories flourish. Science
fiction, as Gibson has pointed out, is a pulp literature, a storytelling
mode in which the plot is the highest priority. These stories demand a
series of ever-raising stakes to keep the tension ratcheting up towards a
climax. Disaster stories in which the small problems of workaday life
are turned into ever-larger problems of “natural” disaster, human
misconduct, worsening disaster, human atrocities, build to an unbeatable
crescendo of man-against-nature-against-man that you can’t bear to look
away from.
As Gibson says, our resonating stories are a window into our collective fears and hopes. We’re still talking about Skynet and The Matrix because the fear of transhuman, immortal colony-organisms that use humans as their energy-source and gut-flora is a great metaphor for the relationship most of us have to limited liability transnational corporations.
This is a common motif of dystopia: neighbor against neighbor, families
turning on each other. In our hearts, we know that we have a common
destiny. Not only are do we require other people to help us accomplish
anything truly ambitious – we also are entwined at the level of our
very microbes, in our very climate. You can’t find high enough ground to
escape climate change, not when the people dying in the lowlands are
breeding antibiotic resistant TB and coughing it into the air we all
breathe. You could try for ever-more baroque secession strategies –
underground shelters, air scrubbers, hydroponics – but at a certain
point, it’s far cheaper to just take care of the people around you and
vice-versa.
The popularity of today’s dystopias might represent the fear of shear
between the contradictions of believing in the primacy of the individual
(and the idea that our shared destiny is a delusion) and the certainty
of the very small and unimaginably large ways in which we are linked. If
we go on believing that we owe each other nothing, we’ll arrive at a
world in which we behave that way – a perfect dystopia.